One Tree Hill - The First Cut is the Deepest Season 1 Episode 16

In the midst of the bitter divorce between Deb and Dan, Nathan has to decide which parent he wants to live with. Dan decides to push Nathan's hand by bribing him with a new car and threatening to reveal a dark secret that Deb has been keeping. Meanwhile, Lucas hooks up with a beautiful stranger who he might be more connected to than he thinks and singer Sheryl Crow stops by Karen's Cafe.